The Examination That Predicts When You Die

Audio article

Uses the speech voice supplied by your browser or device.

THIS IS A WORK OF FICTION

The question paper on every desk was blank except for the first line, which read: Which friend will leave you during the fire?

Underneath, in smaller print, it said: You have forty minutes. Do not turn over until instructed.

Meena stared at it.

She was twelve, the youngest student in the accelerated batch at the Brilliant Minds Coaching Centre in Ballygunge, and she had come that Saturday morning for a mathematics mock examination. The room smelled of floor polish, old paper, and the anxious sweat of fourteen students who had been told that their futures depended on algebra.

The ceiling fans turned slowly, clicking like the second hand of a clock.

“Sir,” said Arjun, a tall boy in the back row, “this isn’t the maths paper.”

Mr. Das, the invigilator, stood beside the door with his arms folded. He was a thin man with a grey moustache that looked as if it had been drawn on with a pencil.

He did not answer.

He only looked at his watch.

“Sir?” Arjun said again.

“Begin,” said Mr. Das.

Meena looked down at her paper.

She had not brought a pen. She had brought two pencils, an eraser, a ruler, and a steel tiffin box containing two luchis and aloo dum, which her grandmother had packed that morning.

She took out a pencil.

The lead was sharp.

She read the first question again.

Which friend will leave you during the fire?

There were four options:

A) The one who borrows your notes
B) The one who laughs the loudest
C) The one who never shares their tiffin
D) The one who sits beside you

Meena felt a chill run down her neck.

She looked at the girl beside her.

Riya was chewing the end of her pen and frowning at her own paper. She had shared her tiffin with Meena only last Tuesday. She had given her half a mango and had pretended not to notice when Meena took the larger piece.

Meena marked D.

She did not know why.

She only knew that the question felt like a door left open in a house where everyone was asleep.

She turned the page.

Question 2: How long can a human remain conscious underground?

A) Three minutes
B) Forty-seven minutes
C) Until the air runs out
D) It depends on what they are waiting for

Meena’s pencil hovered over the paper.

She thought of the time she and her cousin had buried her father’s wristwatch in the garden to see whether time continued underground. They had dug for twenty minutes before her mother caught them. The watch had never worked properly afterward.

She marked B.

Forty-seven minutes.

It seemed like a number someone had measured carefully.

The third question was worse.

Question 3: What sound does a drowning person believe they are making?

A) A whisper
B) Their true name
C) The name of the person who pushed them
D) No sound at all

Meena looked up.

The room was silent except for the scratching of pencils and the clicking of the fans.

Arjun was sweating. His shirt had darkened beneath his arms.

A girl near the front, Priya, was crying silently. Tears ran down her face and fell onto her paper, making small grey circles in the print.

Mr. Das did not move to comfort her.

He only watched.

Meena marked A.

A whisper.

The questions seemed to know things about her that she did not yet know herself.

There were fifty questions.

They grew worse as they went on.

Question 12: Which body part does a person miss first after death?

Question 19: What is the exact weight of a lie told to protect someone?

Question 27: How many times can a heart break before it changes shape?

Question 34: What does the last person to leave a room always forget to turn off?

Question 41: If you could choose the age at which you die, would you tell your mother?

Meena answered them all.

She did not know whether her answers were right or wrong. The questions did not feel as though they had right answers. They felt like traps set by someone who had been watching her for a very long time and had finally decided to ask what she intended to do about it.

When the forty minutes were over, Mr. Das collected the papers.

He did not look at them.

He placed them inside a leather satchel and snapped it shut.

“You may go,” he said. “The results will be posted on Monday.”

The students filed out.

No one spoke.

Meena walked down the stairs and into the street. The heat struck her like a wall. Rickshaws rang their bells. A man at the corner was lowering singaras into a black iron kadai, and the smell of hot oil, pastry, potatoes, and spices made her stomach turn.

She was not hungry.

She had never been less hungry in her life.

At the bus stop, Riya was standing beneath the shade of a banyan tree.

“Did you answer all of them?” Riya asked.

Her eyes were red.

“Yes,” said Meena.

“Some of them felt true,” Riya said. “Like someone had read my diary.”

“I know.”

“What did you put for the fire?”

Meena looked at her.

“I don’t remember.”

It was a lie.

The bus came.

They did not sit together.

Meena looked through the window at shops, crowds, tram wires, broken pavements, and children playing cricket in a lane barely wider than the bat.

Everything looked the same.

Everything felt different.

---

On Monday, Meena arrived at the coaching centre early.

The results had been posted on a board outside Mr. Das’s office.

They were not marks out of one hundred.

They were numbers.

Single numbers.

Ages.

Arjun: 67

Priya: 23

Riya: 81

Debashish: 12

Vikram: 14

Vikram always sat in the corner and rarely spoke. During lessons, he drew aeroplanes in the margins of his notebook. Passenger jets, fighter planes, tiny gliders, and once a machine with six wings that could never possibly have flown.

Meena found her own name at the bottom.

Meena: 100

She stared at it.

One hundred.

She was twelve. A hundred seemed less like an age than a country no one she knew had visited.

It should have felt like victory.

Instead, the number sat on the board like a stone inside her shoe.

“One hundred,” said a voice behind her.

She turned.

Mr. Das stood in the corridor.

He looked different outside the examination room. Smaller, somehow. Tired. His moustache no longer seemed drawn on. It seemed to have been there for a very long time.

“Sir,” Meena said, “what do these numbers mean?”

“You already know.”

“They are ages.”

“Yes.”

“The ages when we die?”

“Unless someone changes them.”

Meena looked again at Vikram’s number.

Fourteen.

He was thirteen.

“What did I score?” she asked.

“One hundred.”

“But these are not marks.”

“Yours is.”

“I don’t understand.”

Mr. Das opened the door to his office.

“Come inside.”

His office was a narrow room containing a desk, two chairs, a steel cabinet, and a wall clock that had stopped at seventeen minutes past four.

Mr. Das closed the door behind them.

“The examination does not test knowledge,” he said. “It tests consistency.”

“What does that mean?”

“It asks questions without clean answers. Most people contradict themselves. They claim they would save a friend and then abandon that friend three questions later. They claim every life is equal, then protect the person they love. They claim they fear death, then choose death rather than shame.”

“And I didn’t?”

“No.”

“So my answers were correct?”

“Not correct in the ordinary sense. The paper found no gap between what you feared, what you believed, and what you would actually do.”

Meena felt colder than she had during the examination.

“What about the numbers outside?”

“They were already written,” Mr. Das said. “You did not cause them.”

The relief lasted only a second.

“Then who did?”

“No one.”

“People don’t simply get assigned numbers.”

Mr. Das looked at the stopped clock.

“People are assigned numbers every day. Doctors call them prognoses. Insurance companies call them risk. Governments call them life expectancy. The universe does not bother giving them names.”

He opened the steel cabinet.

Inside were hundreds of files.

Each file bore a name, a date of birth, and a number written in red ink.

“Every year,” Mr. Das said, “the examination selects one student from one batch. The student who sees most clearly becomes responsible for that batch.”

“Responsible for what?”

“For the numbers.”

Meena’s mouth had gone dry.

“You mean I can change them?”

Mr. Das removed a file from the cabinet and placed it on the desk.

Priya.

“You do not arrange deaths,” he said. “That is a common misunderstanding. You arrange time. You may give someone more of it. You may take it away. The total assigned to your group must remain unchanged.”

Meena did not touch the file.

“This was not an examination,” she said.

“No.”

“It was a job interview.”

“Yes.”

“I don’t want the job.”

“No one does.”

“Then give it to someone else.”

“I cannot.”

“Why?”

“Because no one else scored one hundred.”

Meena stared at him.

Outside the office, a bell rang. Chairs scraped against classroom floors. Somewhere, Mr. Banerjee began explaining quadratic equations in a voice that rose and fell like a song.

Meena looked at Priya’s file.

“What happens if I refuse?”

“The numbers remain as they are.”

“Priya dies at twenty-three.”

“Yes.”

“Vikram dies next year.”

“Yes.”

“And Debashish—”

“Before his thirteenth birthday.”

Meena sat down because her legs would no longer hold her.

“Why children?” she asked.

Mr. Das folded his hands upon the desk.

“Because adults learn to look away. They learn words such as unfortunate, inevitable, collateral, statistical, and necessary. Children have not yet acquired enough vocabulary to hide from what they mean.”

Meena opened Priya’s file.

Inside were photographs, school reports, medical records, and a letter from a cardiologist in Delhi. The papers described an electrical disorder of the heart that would remain undetected until Priya collapsed at twenty-two.

A transplant would become possible after her twenty-sixth birthday.

Her number was twenty-three.

“We can warn her parents,” Meena said.

“You may.”

“Then she can be treated.”

“They may take her to every doctor in India. Unless the number changes, the treatment will come too late, the diagnosis will be missed, the ambulance will be delayed, or the right surgeon will be somewhere else.”

“That makes no sense.”

“It makes perfect sense. You are confusing explanation with cause. The file records how the number fulfills itself. The ledger determines whether it must.”

Mr. Das placed a large book on the desk.

Its leather cover was cracked and dark with age. When he opened it, Meena saw page after page of names and numbers, crossings-out and additions, the handwriting changing from decade to decade.

“This is the ledger,” he said. “The arithmetic is exact.”

Meena looked at him.

“Can I give Priya more time?”

“Yes.”

“Where does it come from?”

“Someone else.”

“Whom?”

“That is your decision.”

“Can I take it from myself?”

Mr. Das watched her for a moment.

“Yes.”

He reached into the cabinet and handed her Vikram’s file.

Fourteen.

Inside was a photograph of Vikram at a school function, holding a certificate. He was smiling. He had a gap between his front teeth.

The medical pages described an inherited disorder of the bone marrow. A compatible donor would be found when he was nineteen.

He would not reach nineteen.

“How much does he need?” Meena asked.

“Five years to reach the donor.”

“And after that?”

“He may live. He may not. The ledger governs the age of death, not whether life is easy.”

“He wants to be a pilot.”

“I know.”

“How long would he need for that?”

“Twenty years would take him to thirty-four.”

“Would he become one?”

“The ledger does not promise occupations.”

“But he would have time to try.”

“Yes.”

Meena looked at her own name.

“If I give him twenty, I live to eighty.”

“Unless you alter it again.”

“Eighty is old.”

“It is older than most allocators leave themselves.”

Meena picked up the pen lying beside the ledger.

It was heavier than it looked.

She wrote Vikram’s name.

Beside fourteen, she crossed out the number and wrote thirty-four.

Beside her own name, she changed one hundred to eighty.

Nothing happened.

No thunder sounded. No light entered the room. The stopped clock did not begin moving again.

Mr. Das closed Vikram’s file.

“It is done,” he said.

Meena opened Priya’s file again.

“How much does she need?”

“Three years would allow her to reach the transplant list. Ten would give her a better chance of surviving it.”

Meena subtracted ten from her own number.

Seventy.

Priya became thirty-three.

Then she opened Debashish’s file.

His asthma was severe. At sixteen, he would become eligible for a treatment programme his family could not presently afford. His number was twelve.

Meena gave him five years.

Seventeen.

Not enough for a whole life.

Enough to reach the treatment.

She continued.

Six years went to a girl named Nandini, whose school bus would fall from a bridge.

Eight went to Rohan, whose fever would be mistaken for something harmless.

Four went to Salma, who would survive an operation if the surgeon had seven more minutes.

Four went to Tuhin, who would otherwise step from a pavement at the wrong moment on a rainy evening.

By the time Meena reached the final page, she had given away another twenty-two years.

Her number was forty-three.

The pen had begun to hurt her fingers.

Mr. Das looked at the ledger.

“That is young.”

“It is older than fourteen.”

“You used only your own years.”

“Yes.”

“You are permitted to take from others.”

“I know.”

“Some allocators take from the old and give to the young. Some take from the cruel and give to the kind. Some decide that a scientist deserves more time than a thief. Some decide the opposite.”

“How do they know who deserves it?”

“They do not.”

“Then why do they do it?”

“Because eventually they become tired of dying in place of strangers.”

Meena closed the ledger.

The sound echoed through the small office.

“I will decide that next year,” she said.

Mr. Das almost smiled.

“That is what they all say in the beginning.”

Meena stood.

“How many allocators are there?”

“Many. One is selected each year. Each remains responsible for the students who sat the examination with them.”

“So I only decide for our class?”

“For now.”

“What does that mean?”

Mr. Das did not answer.

Instead, he opened the steel cabinet again and removed a steel tiffin box. It was old, scratched, and polished smooth around the clasp by generations of hands.

“This box belonged to the first allocator selected at this centre,” he said. “The food inside was packed this morning by last year’s allocator.”

Meena took the box.

It was warm.

“Why?”

“Tradition.”

“Who was last year’s allocator?”

“A boy from the senior batch.”

“How old is he?”

“Thirteen.”

Meena looked at the tiffin box.

“What is inside?”

“Luchi and aloo dum.”

She opened it.

There was one luchi wrapped in paper and a small container of potatoes spiced with cumin, ginger, and mustard seeds.

The smell reminded her so strongly of her grandmother’s kitchen that her eyes filled with tears.

“The first meal after the ledger is always given by someone who understands,” Mr. Das said.

“Understands what?”

“That you will be hungry afterward.”

Meena sat at the desk and ate.

The luchi had become chewy. The potatoes were still warm in the middle. She ate slowly, wiping the gravy from the steel container with the last piece of bread.

For the first time since Saturday, she felt hungry.

When she finished, she closed the tiffin box.

“What happens now?”

“Now you go to class.”

“And after that?”

“You study. You grow up. You become a doctor, a teacher, a pilot, or whatever else you choose. On the third Saturday of every July, you return here. You read the new pages in your files. You may revise the numbers.”

“Why would the files change?”

“Because people change. Roads are built. Medicines are invented. Wars begin. Parents move. Children become adults and make foolish decisions.”

“But the total stays the same.”

“Always.”

Meena looked at the ledger.

“You said I must not tell the others.”

“That is the first rule.”

“Why?”

“Because people who know their numbers stop living normally. Those with high numbers become careless. Those with low numbers become frightened. Both often arrive at the same place sooner.”

Meena picked up her schoolbag.

At the door, she stopped.

“What is the second rule?”

Mr. Das looked toward the steel cabinet.

“Never make a change while angry.”

“And the third?”

“Never believe that balancing the ledger makes it fair.”

Meena left the office.

The corridor was bright. Students sat in their classrooms. She could hear Mr. Banerjee explaining how a quadratic equation could have two answers, one answer, or none at all.

She walked down the stairs and pushed open the heavy front door.

The heat struck her.

Rickshaws rang their bells. A dog barked in a lane. The singara seller stood over his kadai, lowering another batch into the oil. The smell of fried pastry and spiced potatoes drifted across the pavement.

Riya was waiting at the gate.

“Where were you?” she asked. “Maths started ten minutes ago.”

“I had to do something.”

“What?”

Meena looked at her friend.

Riya was twelve.

Unless the ledger changed, she would live to eighty-one.

Meena had not taken a single year from her.

“Nothing important,” Meena said. “Come on. We’re late.”

They walked into the classroom together.

Mr. Banerjee looked up but did not ask where they had been. He pointed toward their desks.

“Turn to page forty-seven,” he said. “Quadratic equations. The examination is in three weeks. You must be ready.”

Meena opened her book.

She took out her pencil.

The lead was still sharp.

The equations were clean. They had rules. A number moved from one side to the other and changed its sign. Whatever was subtracted in one place had to be accounted for somewhere else.

She solved the first equation.

It had one right answer.

She moved to the second.

Outside, the fans clicked. The singara seller called his wares. A bus groaned at the crossing. The city went on, not knowing what had been changed in a small office on the second floor.

Meena wrote her name at the top of the page.

She underlined it twice.

She was twelve.

Her number was forty-three.

Vikram would have time to find the donor. Priya would reach the transplant list. Debashish might reach the treatment that would let him run without wheezing.

None of it was certain except the arithmetic.

Meena looked at the second equation.

For a moment, she imagined the ledger open beneath it, every life reduced to figures moved from one column to another.

Then the bell rang for tiffin.

The children poured into the corridor.

Meena closed her book and ran with them because she was twelve, because the singara seller was waiting at the gate, and because the day was hot and bright and full of everything she had given away.